Menu Adam R Brown

Notes navigation: Browse by titleBrowse by authorSubject index

Lupia, Levine, Menning, and Sin: Were Bush tax cut supporters simply ignorant

Disclaimer. Don't rely on these old notes in lieu of reading the literature, but they can jog your memory. As a grad student long ago, my peers and I collaborated to write and exchange summaries of political science research. I posted them to a wiki-style website. "Wikisum" is now dead but archived here. I cannot vouch for these notes' accuracy, nor can I even say who wrote them. If you have more recent summaries to add to this collection, send them my way I guess. Sorry for the ads; they cover the costs of keeping this online.

Lupia, Levine, Menning, and Sin. 2005. Were Bush tax cut supporters 'simply ignorant?' A second look at conservatives and liberals in 'Homer Gets a Tax Cut.' Unpublished.

Argument

Bartels (2005) argued in "Homer Gets a Tax Cut" that most of those supporting Bush's 2001 tax cuts were simply ignorant. He regresses political information against support for the tax cuts and finds a statistically significant negative relationship. However, Lupia et al show that Bartels neglected to consider that information has opposite effects depending on ideology/party.

For liberals, it is true that support for Bush's tax cuts when down (significantly) with increasing information. But for conservatives, the opposite was true (but with a weaker relationship). Because information had a stronger effect (slope) on liberals than on conservatives, Bartels found his (spurious) results.

Lupia et al use these results to remind us not to be too quick to conclude that those who disagree with us are simply ignorant. People have reasons for their opinions. Sometimes, we need to look a little harder in order to find those reasons, but we should not assume that people are irrational or ignorant.

Evidence

Lupia et al replicate Bartels (columns 1 and 2 in table 1), then run the same regression separately for Democrats, Republicans, conservatives, and liberals. The find that information has statistically significant, negative effects on support for the tax cuts among Democrats and liberals; but the same variable has weakly positive (not significant) effects among Republicans and conservatives.

Compare Figure 1 (summarizes Bartels) with Figure 2.

Research by the same authors

Research on similar subjects

Tags

Lupia, Arthur (author)Levine, Adam Seth (author)Menning, Jesse (author)Sin, Gisela (author)Political ScienceAmerican PoliticsInformationKnowledgeVotingRetrospective Voting

Wikisum home: Index of all summaries by title, by author, or by subject.